Thursday, May 28, 2020

A Temporary win


All good things come to an end, does that mean all terrible things end too? I didn’t quite know whether I should be grateful for the second thought or fearful of the first? On an everyday Sunday morning in October 1972, when our maid went to my father’s room to give him his morning tea and found him quite dead, I knew only part of my troubles were done. I am sure the preface to a story explains everything, introduces the characters and their motivations. However, real-life doesn’t work like that. To know what makes someone tick and how the world goes, would solve most of our existential crisis…. but no, life doesn’t work like that. To point the obvious, life is messy and cruel but sometimes quite funny if you can see the humour in such morbid stuff, which I do.
So to set the scene, on a usual Sunday morning, our maid brings my baba his tea, she walks to the door and knocks on it, three times, quite timid and uncertain. My father had a temper, he was infamous for it, and he didn’t just use his words, sometimes his fist did some of the talking too. When he didn’t answer, she looked at me questioningly; I shrugged in response and went back to sipping my tea. She started calling him, “Babu! Babu?” At first a little hesitant she picked up in tempo and pitch, “BABU!” I looked at her, annoyed and a bit alarmed, she is asking for a good talking to if she keeps on with her screeching and baba definitely will use his fists now. This went on for quite some time and by then the whole house had gathered around the verandah that leads to his room, some of our neighbours also had joined in. We had a huge joint family and we had been living in a partially shared huge shambling “heritage” home (or palace) built by our ancestors in North Calcutta, so everyone knew everyone’s business or at least tried to.  Hence, when baba didn’t answer our maids beckoning for almost half an hour, quite a crowd gathered outside his room. Amidst this commotion, I tried to hide my feelings of euphoria and utter despair, it wasn’t really difficult; no one was bothered about me. They were preoccupied with my father’s curious silence.
Finally, few able-bodied men brought down the door while the women stood watching on the sidelines and whispering amongst themselves. It was quite a show and I was enjoying myself by now. The door gave up with a massive thud and a rush of warm air rushed in from outside, dust motes floated in the sunlight. For a moment, everyone stood still. Not quite sure of what to do next. I cleared my throat and stepped in the dark room, a sliver of sunbeam showing me the way. The room was in disarray, it seemed someone had carelessly thrown books, papers, and clothes around, or was it baba in his last stages of agony grasped at every material thing he could get hold of. I walked to the nearest window and threw it open, the bright light stung our eyes now used to the dark room. I heard a gasp and few screams, I turned to find my father, lying limp on the floor, his eyes staring at nothing and his body contorted in those last moments of death spasms. I knew I had to pretend to be shocked and distraught, somehow the shock of seeing him dead did the trick and I fell into blackness.
The important thing when talking about your father, with whom you seem to have no love lost, is not to go overboard with showing how distressed you were at his demise. A balance between shock, sadness, and indifference is the key. I sat across the inspector from the Lalbazar police station and tried to emulate the right amount of emotions.
“Mr. Sen, did your father have any enemies?” The inspector meant business, but I was surprised at the question. Did they suspect something? I thought they had not ruled out natural causes yet or had they?
“I am not sure what you mean, my father was a respected businessman and he had been in the family publishing business all his life. It’s true he came across as intimidating and had some professional rivals…but these are part and parcel of normal life, how can that be related to his death? Do you have evidence suspecting anything other than natural causes?” The best I could do, but I think I did well. The inspector cleared his throat; he seemed to be in some discomfort.
“We still need to perform proper medical procedures before commenting on anything else, but the circumstances seem a little suspicious, don’t you think so?” He looked at me, probing for a response or clue. Maybe I was being paranoid.
“I am sorry, I can’t help you with your speculations. I am a doctor, a man of science and I don’t believe in idle speculations. He was perfectly well last night; he finished his dinner at 9 and went straight to bed. My father had his share of illness and he had been suffering from low immunity and high blood pressure for the last few years nothing too serious though…I did treat him for a while but unfortunately, he didn’t have much trust in allopathy; he was a devout believer in homeopathy… so he made his own concoctions and followed his own prescriptions. I would wait for the autopsy report before commenting further.” I took a deep breath and glanced at the clock. It was way past noon, how time flies. The inspector stood up, shook my hand, and took his leave. I breathed a sigh of relief. I was not yet allowed in his room but I was itching to go in again, did I forget anything? Years of meticulous planning but a vague doubt remains, did I forget anything?
The next few days passed in a haze…people coming to pay their respects and fuel their own curiosity, lawyers discussing property and deeds, friends and family offering their sympathetic ears and of course, police playing a game of quid pro quo, the information in exchange for information. It seems the death had baffled them; there was no evidence of foul play yet not everything fell into place. The autopsy didn’t reveal much. Although, the reason for his death was clear. It was atropine poisoning, a compound that came from his personal medical concoction of belladonna. It’s common knowledge that sometimes in homeopathy deadly poisons are used for treatments albeit in very low concentrations. Belladonna is known for its use in useful for fevers, high blood pressure and baba had been taking this poison for quite some time. I think what baffled the police was why would he overdose on something that must have been routine to him? The room was locked from inside, they couldn’t find any evidence of forceful entry. The bottle of his belladonna pills was the same that he had used for a few years. Except his blood toxicity painted another story…so they were baffled. They couldn’t find any motive for his family members, my mother had been dead for a while and I had my own practice and life separate from his…the property was equally divided among his cousins and there was no petty squabble regarding property or money, in principle, we were the perfect joint family, a picture of wealth and happiness.   Did he kill himself? After a month had passed they passed a judgment of accidental consumption of high dosage of belladonna and that was that. Case closed.
            All good things must come to an end. Trouble started brewing in paradise when I couldn’t sleep anymore. Was it guilty conscience? Why should I punish myself for a deed well done? I would spend most of the night pacing back and forth; the clock from his room was still ticking…should I stop its hand too? The clock went on, tick-tock and I paced on, no wonder people were getting concerned about me. A fresh bout of sympathy and curiosity ensued this episode of sleeplessness and I felt trapped in the web of well-meaning conversations. I decided to sell my portion of the house and move on, I could kill the connection to the damned house and to baba for good. Life has a funny sense of humour too if one could look past the ugliness and pain. I should have known baba would haunt me even after his death.
The paperwork was done pretty fast, and I was almost done packing up, putting my life in boxes and suitcases.  Many of our cousins and their assorted families expressed their grief and concern about my leaving; a branch of the family tree was broken. I tried to console them by false promises, but maybe they knew I was relieved to go. Meanwhile, the clock went on tick-tocking and I went on pacing. Don’t they say, life is motion and in stillness one finds death. Strangely no one talks about peace, does one find peace in death too? I knew my time was up but before I left everything behind, I wanted to go inside his room. The sensible part of me warned against it, the servants would move the essential stuff and the lawyers would take care of the legal matters, I don’t need to go inside. Yet, another part of me really wanted to sneak a peek. I knew I would regret it but going against my better judgment, on the last night before I left for good I slipped inside baba’s room. It was a Thursday night, everyone was fast asleep, I waited till the clock struck 3 am and tiptoed towards his room. The room was locked but I had sneaked the bundle of keys from the wooden key-holder that hung on the kitchen wall during dinner. I kept them in the pocket of my pajamas, feeling their weight on my thighs and in my heart. Waiting for everyone to settle down in their rooms was painstaking; I had to pretend to be in bed as well. I covered myself in the cotton sheet, turning on my left side facing the door of my room. I kept chasing shadows beneath the door as everyone moved about the house before retiring for the day. As I got my chance, the clock struck 3; I sneaked past their rooms to baba’s room, nimbly and softly like a cat. But my heart was pounding, I wondered if they could hear it?
The lock wouldn’t give in; I had to struggle with quite a few keys in the bundle. One would think the servants or a house member would have the common sense to keep the key to his place separate from the other ones, but no such luck of course. I chanced upon the right key on my fourth try, heaving a sigh of relief, I turned the key and opened the door as quietly as I could. The room was musty like an old library. It didn’t smell like him. Baba had disappeared, his essence and presence had vanished with his earthly body, it seemed he never existed. I relished the feeling of his absence. I wasn’t really sure what was I looking for? His personal belongings and his little cabinet of homeopathy had been searched and ransacked thoroughly by the police. If they couldn’t find anything, why should I? Yet I knew him, intimately, with a passion they didn’t possess, and if baba had to hide something I would know where wouldn’t I? I had been adding tiny doses of atropine to his medicinal concoction gradually but the fatal dose was an accident on my part, wasn’t it? I wanted him to linger on a bit before the end. Maybe, it was not an accident, I remembered slipping into his room in the afternoon, putting atropine into his bottle of medicine, maybe I went overboard emptying the vial into the dark amber bottle. No one suspected and baba was dead. Why was I here? I went through his desk, the drawers, and bedside table; there was nothing of interest just old yellowing documents, bills, handwritten scribbling, and such…there was nothing. Yet, there was something, I couldn’t find his little box, the enameled ornate jewelry box his mother had left him. Baba was very close to the little piece and kept it beside his bed. Where was it? I had started to perspire, the sweat making it difficult to keep my movements soft and supple like a cat, I felt more like a weasel. I should go, I thought; I had almost given up when I saw it. The light from the street caught a sharp edge of silver beneath the almirah. There it was! Gleaming slyly at me, I went down on my knees, stretching my hand to fish it out from the dust and dirt. Almost there…got it! My mind leaped in joy. What treasures would it hold for me? There were no locks on it; I blew on the cover, coughing with the copious amount of dust. My heart stopped for a moment. Did they hear me? I stood still, my ears pricked for any noise. A moment or two had passed before I felt safe, I sat gingerly at the corner of his bed and pried open the box.
I could never explain why I had decided to kill baba. Was it because of his cruelty towards his children? His temper? Indifference? Or was it because I grew tired of him and his theatrics? I can never say but I think the moment I looked into the box I knew why. It was stark except for a piece of paper, folded neatly. Did he expect me to find it? I put the box down on the bed and opened the little note he had left for me. It simply read, “I knew it was you, I will find you in hell.” The note fell from my hand, he knew but he still took his medicine. Why? Just to jab at me? My short-lived victory of getting rid of him was over; he won again, even in his death.


Saturday, June 22, 2019

The man who felt a whole lot of pain and had anger issues


Image result for arjun reddy vs. kabir singh  sketch
Lately I’ve had some time on my own and often found myself chasing down the rabbit hole of YouTube (uninspired I know, but quite interesting at times I swear!). I had come across the trailer of “Kabir Singh” some months ago and the movie had released recently in India and across the world. Recently reviews of the movie would keep popping up in my YouTube home screen. I wasn’t particularly thrilled by the trailer, seemed like any other Bollywood love story, very mainstream and very masala. Too much masala over the years had burnt my taste buds so I preferred plain vanilla movies portraying a slice of life, for instance, the likes of “Masaan”, “Newton”, even quirky comedies and not quite vanilla flicks like “Mard ko dard nahi hota” really satisfied me. I would have anyway given “Kabir Singh” a pass but I was interested in what other film critics and reviewers had to say about it. The reviews were mixed but some points made by the more discerning critic seemed a tad problematic. Other people who loved the film said much ado about nothing, it’s not about toxic masculinity but it’s a character study. My interest was piqued, but I wasn’t ready to shell out money to watch it on the silver screen. So I opted to watch the original one in Telegu, “Arjun Reddy” (still available on Amazon Prime!). I decided to spend two hours and some minutes of my life watching a film I wasn’t particularly invested in, reading subtitles and questioning my very existence? What the heck am I doing with my life?
What I was left with after two hours and some minutes was whiplash from memories of my college days, not very pleasant ones and a bad taste in my mouth. What was the point of this? What did the director want to say with this script and this movie? I am not sure. I mean, sure not all movies need to have social message, some films are massy and they are just entertaining. But how is this entertaining? Okay maybe to some people and sure it’s a character study, not all heroes are well heroic, some are flawed, maybe this character wasn’t a hero at all, but he was the protagonist and it was his perspective. I mean the female lead didn’t have much to say anyway, not to him, not to her controlling father and when she did speak it was never more than a whisper. A person having no issues with picking fights over football matches and broken glasses faces little to no punishment for his atrocious behaviour. The only character I rather liked in the whole drama the grandma dies! The scenes played for comedy were just plain creepy and strange, running after a maid like a man possessed when she broke his glass was supposed to be funny, pulling a knife on a one-night stand to force get to take off her clothes was also supposed to be funny and of course the most bizarre “funny” scene, making a “fat chick” sit beside a “pretty chick” because “fat chicks are like teddy bears, warm and loyal” and a “pretty girl” should always have a “fat” (read ugly) friend. This really happened in the movie. I was just flabbergasted, what am I supposed to make of it? Let’s talk about his redeeming qualities; his is super smart and almost a genius, from a high society, privileged family. All these factors help him to come almost unscathed from his extremely self destructive and abusive behaviour. He is so unprofessional that he shows up in surgery drunk, then when the hospital sues him for malpractice and misconduct, he gets away because of his affluent family, pays fines whatever (but not enough, his ass should have been in jail full-stop!). Sure his grandma dies (I was sad for her more than he was) maybe he suffered through her death and losing his love interest. I don’t know, what are we celebrating here? If this is masculinity I prefer Newton’s (not the physicist but the protagonist in the movie with the same name) masculinity to this (he stood up for his principles, fair elections, went to insane lengths for it). I would also like to mention how the ragging showed in the film brought back very bad memories. I had been an engineering student, as a fresher I felt those smarts and insults, forced to address the seniors as “Ma’am” “Sir” for no good reason, how rudely they would call us like we were dogs and of course first year girls were treated like fresh meat by the senior boys. I hated it! This film showed all of it, there was even a scene when Arjun says “this girl is mine, but the rest is yours” or something to the like to his friends, marking his territory and graciously sharing the rest of the fresh meat aka first year girls with his buddies. I thought we were past this, I thought I left this behind in 2006. Maybe I live in a bubble, I felt our society had changed over time but we are still making and watching such stories. The girl, Arjun’s love interest (I don't think anyone noticed so far I have never mentioned her name, is that important?) speaks in full sentences only after they made love, her father pushes her to marry some other guy of the same caste, he slaps her and she also slaps him not at the same moment though, she is pregnant but of course is “pure”, she left the marriage in 3 days  “My husband didn’t touch me even with his little finger, the baby is yours” she says to him towards the end of the film, but don’t forget dear friends she also has an MBBS degree and is about the same age as our hero…I was thinking at this point, what the hell am I watching? I will admit I had to forward few scenes to move it to the end (it was too bloody long!) but yes I have watched this to the bitter end.
I was having a conversation about this movie with someone, he said would any one watch this film if it was a female character who had anger issues and was abusive, I could only say it’s not about females or males, it is a flawed character who is angry and abusive. But then I thought "Arjun" or "Kabir"  does get away with it, with everything he did (and the poor grandma does die) and he also gets the girl at the end. Did he change over the course of the film, was there a character arc, barely more like a flat arc! Does he mellow down, maybe, but the film does not dwell on that, even when he apologizes to his patients for being a dick to them it is in the background of a song (in the same scene he cries over a plate of biryani, that was pretty hilarious to me!). Jokes apart did this person have a point, would our society let a female get away with such atrocious behaviour with a mere slap on the knuckles and off you go to a better life (without the grandma, that was brutal man!). In closing I would like to say sure character studies are fun and not all heroes are perfect, people are flawed but what is this story about really? We need to ask our selves that, are we not disturbed by the blatant disregard of human decency towards “fat chicks”, “pretty chicks”, awesome grandmas, families, friends (he treats his father and brother like shit), professional ethics and of course consent. I think this was the disturbing part, the one-night stand said no he pulled a knife, the female lead is never asked “do you want to cut classes and study with me” and so on. She is never asked and she always complies, I am disturbed by that, are you?

Tuesday, July 31, 2018

Change

College transported me to a new town, where I tried, one more time, to reinvent myself. Becoming someone new, I could correct the errors of my past. At first I was optimistic; I could pull it off. But in the end, no matter where I went, I could never change." - Haruki Murakami


I have always been the one for change. Often stuck in time and place, I have longed for not even better things just things to be different…but over the years whenever I have changed places, situations and people, I seemed to have stayed the same… People say that cells regenerate and after every seven years all the cells in one’s body are replaced, so does that mean the person stays the same? It is this same question poised and explored in a film called the “Ship of Theseus” (a must watch!). Theseus' paradox is whether an object that has all of its components replaced remains fundamentally the same object or does it become something else…I don’t have an answer, in fact I don’t seem to have an answer for a lot of things these days, so I thought instead I would just ask questions…why not right?

Another thing has bothered me for quite some time is the fact that I can’t be objective about any situation or person, I would always try to relate in a more personal way to them and my opinions about people and situations are often tainted by my personal thoughts and feelings…and I suddenly remembered the thought experiment I had read about electrons wave-particle duality), I guess in the 11th standard in school…a simple set-up with a gun that shoots electrons at a wall having two tiny slits that can be either opened or closed. Once they pass through the slit, or slits, the electrons would hit a detector. The experiment explained how if a single slit were opened the electrons would behave like a particle but if two slits were open, then the electrons would form interference patterns (light and dark fringes, depending on the fact when the waves add to the wavelength or the regions where peaks and troughs would overlap to cancel each other creating alternating patches of light and dark areas) characteristics of light waves. I was fascinated with this idea. Can we ever know something absolutely by itself because the observer would always change the object! Amazing!
So the question is do we really change over time and if we do, how we measure it? What if the reference point no longer exists?

Tuesday, September 20, 2016

Melancholia

“For some nights I slept profoundly; but still every morning I felt the same lassitude, and a languor weighed upon me all day. I felt myself a changed girl. A strange melancholy was stealing over me, a melancholy that I would not have interrupted. Dim thoughts of death began to open, and an idea that I was slowly sinking took gentle, and, somehow, not unwelcome possession of me. If it was sad, the tone of mind which this induced was also sweet. Whatever it might be, my soul acquiesced in it.” 
― J. Sheridan Le FanuCarmilla

Melancholia - deep sadness or gloom; melancholy.

Looking out my window at the beautiful sunset, I felt a perverse joy in being morbid and indulging in my melancholia…and then I asked myself this question, which would be the easiest way to put an end to my life? A bullet to the head (what if I miss and am maimed for life!! Can that happen?), or hanging oneself by the neck (would the ceiling fan withstand my weight?) or drifting to death with sleeping pills? (How many should one take? Is it really as peaceful as it sounds or is there some pain involved which one couldn’t possibly avoid?)…Too many questions again and too less of answers! Before things get too morbid and serious, I would just like to point out that these are mere speculations with no grounds in reality whatsoever and the main reason for this is…I just love myself too much! I guess killing myself would have to wait; maybe I would just leave it to father time (or is it mother?). But why think about this at all? I feel we are often confronted by our mortality, and people react to it differently…I had been pondering on this for quite sometime, and somehow recently I have come across so many references on this topic (for instance, the other day I saw a graffiti which read “Things to do before I die”, and people wrote what they would like to do before the end beneath those words!) that I couldn’t really avoid talking (or ranting more likely) about it! Lets talk about the bucket list first, when did it become literally the talk of the town? How can it be less depressing to talk about things to do before one kicks the good old bucket? I mean what if I can’t do most of the things I would like to do before I die? Like looking at the northern lights or the Aurora Borealis, knowing fully well how much of a spoiled brat I am that I might not be able to survive the harsh conditions (and for the love of God I can’t camp or hike or trek or do anything outdoorsy, because I am useless I guess?), so before meandering too much I’ll come to the topic at hand, I really can’t understand how listing things I would like to do before the grand finale would make the impending doom of my death less scary and depressing? I really don’t know…also life has this funny way of throwing twists and turns in your face when you might be having different plans for it all together!

I would like to go a little off topic now, there was this one video I saw sometime ago on YouTube about “Melancholia” and it spoke about how it is healthy to be depressed and give in to sadness once in a while…Society pressurizes us to be happy all the time and to deal away with any sense of self-doubt or pity or bleakness which are, to be fair, valid parts of the human condition! The most beautiful songs or poems or stories are poignantly sad…then why when someone asks you on the road “How are you doing?” one is obliged to say “I am fine!” even though they might be feeling quite contrary to what they are saying…and while we are still ranting I must say I hate saying “I am fine” or hearing someone say, “I am fine”, I mean what does it even mean to say you are fine! On some days when I am feeling especially blue and someone asks me how am I doing, I feel like saying “I am not good, I feel so sad and overwhelmed…” but instead I end up saying something banal such as “I am doing good!” or “I am fine!”…This contradiction in people’s behaviour and expectation has puzzled me for so long, I mean on hand one is forced to be cheery all the time and then one has to think about making a bucket list which is actually quite a morbid thing to do…I mean what’s the point? I know I would die eventually but I am happy to do so?!! What the heck!!

Maybe there is no good answer to this question and people would do things as they are expected to do anyway, but it felt good nevertheless to go on a rant and vent out my  “melancholia”.

“Melancholia is, I believe, a musical problem: a dissonance, a change in rhythm. While on the outside everything happens with the vertiginous rhythm of a cataract, on the inside is the exhausted adagio of drops of water falling from time to tired time. For this reason the outside, seen from the melancholic inside, appears absurd and unreal, and constitutes ‘the farce we all must play’. But for an instant – because of a wild music, or a drug, or the sexual act carried to its climax – the very slow rhythm of the melancholic soul does not only rise to that of the outside world: it overtakes it with an ineffably blissful exorbitance, and the soul then thrills animated by delirious new energies” 
― Alejandra Pizarnik



Friday, September 16, 2016

Pointless

In a mad dash to connect with someone,
I lose the connection I have with myself…
On a star filled night or in a desolate town,
Or on a highway lined with traffic…
I reach out for something or someone,
Knowing fully well how my search would end in vain,
‘Cause we are islands, connected by nothing and no one…
‘Cause our pleasure and our pain are our own to bear….
Yet I would reach out again and again, quite in vain.